Desktop Security Software Risks - Part 2

This is the third in a series of articles highlighting reasons why we need a new model for anti-virus and security solutions.

Reason #2: the Desktop Security Software Risks

The risks of placing software on the desktop are such that I will be breaking this article into two parts.

There are many advantages to putting security and anti-virus software on the desktop. They range from efficiency to money. Under previous ways of thinking if I can capture security and virus problems at the desktop I can prevent them from going any farther. That works well in a non-connected environment. In the connected environment it makes more sense to centralize the software and monitor connections in and out. Basically "firewall" all the appliances from each other.

In a previous article we discussed the security risks inherent with desktop software designed to be the protection layer between you and all those bad people out there on the Internet. Here now we will discuss some more mundane issues regarding the risks of putting security software on the desktop:

Drag

Drag steals clock-cycles from your processes so that it can run in a higher priority mode. Anti-virus software especially places a drag on your computer. Depending on your settings (and the default settings are usually very aggressive), every time you run a program or open a file, real-time file scanning takes place and your files are scanned for viruses. This slows down your processing. Accessing larger files takes longer. You can see a discernible lag time between when you start a program/open a file and when you can actually access it.

Compatibility

After the obvious issue of "drag" is compatibility. Often security and anti-virus rules get in the way of your doing business on your computer. While you may get away with using older versions of such packages as Word, Sims, Photoshop, etc. on your computer with the new XP operating system, it's unlikely your security software will be completely compatible. Why? Many packages rely on very low-level functionality to be able to do the tasks they set out to do. Anti-virus packages have to be able to operate at a level closer to the hardware than most packages. They need to do this to prevent virus software from taking precedence from them. While many packages offer backward-compatibility the opposite is not true: forward-compatibility. There are several reasons for this: a package written for Windows 98 will not anticipate all the changes to the operating system that are implemented for Windows XP. While your Win98 anti-virus program may work under XP, it won't work at its peak performance. It can't. It's just another reason for centralizing your security. By siphoning all your traffic through a security screen at your ISP, for instance, you offload the need for updates and staying up-to-date on your security software. This then becomes the job of the service provider.

Updates

Having the software on your desktop means you are responsible for maintaining that software. In the case of office productivity software or image editing software, if new versions come out with features you're not interested in, you don't update. With new viruses appearing on the landscape every day, you can't afford not to continually update your software. If you don't update for a month or two, you run severe risks of infection. You also will incur potential long update cycles as your software has to be upgraded to handle all the new threats.

This makes the desktop these days a somewhat ineffective solution. Nearly two-thirds of all the PCs that have anti-virus protection installed do not update their definitions regularly. These PCs might as well uninstall the software for all the good it's doing them.

Lost Time

As mentioned in the above discussion, you can lose considerable time if you don't update regularly. Long intervals between updates can translate into long update cycles. If you have a slow connection to a vendor, your down time is much longer as you have to wait for the files to be downloaded and then you have to wait for your software to update itself.

Solution

The better solution is to move to a centralized solution in which all the software, all the updates are the responsibility of the service provider. You pay for the service of having your email cleaned before you receive it. When email arrives at your service provider's mailbox, it is checked for malicious tendencies and stripped if bad. You notice no long waiting, no downtime, no drag, no incompatibilities.

About The Author

Tim Klemmer
CEO, OnceRed LLC
http://www.checkinmyemail.com

Tim Klemmer has spent the better part of 12 years designing and perfecting the first true patented behavior-based solution to malicious software.

timklemmer@checkinmyemail.com

Related News

McCain Outlines Technology Policy - Broadcasting & Cable McCain Outlines Technology Policy Broadcasting & Cable, NY -8 hours ago The tech policy section of the site also suggests McCain will favor personal responsibility and technological fixes for controlling content. ... Politics a-Go-Go on the Web - InternetNews.com Politics a-Go-Go on the Web InternetNews.com -4 hours ago ... to see or what restaurants to go to, said Andrew Rasiej, founder of the Personal Democracy Forum, a site focused on how technology is changing politics. ... Personal Tech: ABCs of online security - Salt Lake Tribune Personal Tech: ABCs of online security Salt Lake Tribune, United States -Aug 12, 2008 Boulder, Colorado - More than 18 million college students will head back to school this fall and nearly every one of them owns a personal computer. ... Tech Weekly: Windows 7 and location based services - guardian.co.uk Tech Weekly: Windows 7 and location based services guardian.co.uk, UK -13 hours ago Is the trend towards personalisation encroaching on our personal privacy, or will it break down the boundaries, and make the web work for us all? ... Tech Mahindra’s future, sans BT - Livemint Tech Mahindra’s future, sans BT Livemint, India -4 hours ago Here are some figures: on 23 June 2006, personal loans constituted 27.33% of total non-food credit outstanding, while credit to the infrastructure sector ... Here, there, everywhere . . . where am I? - Atlanta Journal Constitution Here, there, everywhere . . . where am I? Atlanta Journal Constitution,  USA -9 hours ago My thoughts are increasingly disjointed as I wind down my final few days covering Tech as there are a lot of loose ends to tie up professionally, etc., ... TECH BLOG One Less Windows User - LinuxInsider.com TECH BLOG One Less Windows User LinuxInsider.com, CA -12 hours ago By Jason Z. Cohen After nearly five years, I needed to update my personal computer. My old Dell Inspiron has long since been rendered quaint by advances in ... Jews aim to use tech tactics to counter anti-Obama 'rumor mill' - Ha'aretz Jews aim to use tech tactics to counter anti-Obama 'rumor mill' Ha'aretz, Israel -Aug 26, 2008 "It's micro-targeting, it works through your personal network ? the activists are just getting tools to do it effectively". "Technically, it's pretty simple ... Jewish Obama backers to fight rumorsPolitico all 22 news articles Personal Tech: iPhone just got smarter - Salt Lake Tribune Personal Tech: iPhone just got smarter Salt Lake Tribune, United States -Aug 19, 2008 By Vince Horiuchi "Crash Kart,"a Mario Kart-like driving game, is shown running on Apple's new iPhone 3G. With all the hoopla over the iPhone 3G and its new ... N-Power announces Tech Pragati scholarships - Economic Times N-Power announces Tech Pragati scholarships Economic Times, India -7 hours ago Scholarships upto 50% of the course fees will be awarded to meritorious students on the basis of their performance in an aptitude test and a personal...